Adobe – Inconsitent View of Open Source?
Posted by dougr | Posted in Adobe, CF, Flex | Posted on 04-04-2008
Tags: ColdFusion, Flex, Open Source
5
Has Adobe’s reaction to the open sourcing of Blue Dragon revealed inconsistencies across product lines related to open source culture?
Last week on The Flex Show Jeffry Houser discussed his displeasure about how the Adobe ColdFusion team had responded to the announcement of New Atlanta’s J2EE open source release of Blue Dragon, the competition to ColdFusion. The main issue which he mentioned was related to the response from the CF team in a ‘negative connotation’ toward open sourcing – this is in the wake of Flex3 open-source releases. The main point was that there seems to be inconsistency of views between the Adobe Flex and ColdFusion Teams. Jeffry spoke that the CF Team Members made such statements as ‘New Atlanta is conceding the market’ and they are ‘abandoning it’ by open sourcing Blue Dragon. Jeffry posed the question ‘Does this mean that Flex open sourcing is conceding the market’ or ‘abandoning it’.
Although Jeffry did not mention any specific Adobe team member names, I was intrigued by his comments and did some looking around to find some articles that seemed aligned with Jeffry’s comments. At the top of the list I found this entry in Damon Cooper’s Blog which discussed the open sourcing of Blue Dragon as a matter of conceding to ColdFusion. There were others, but none quite so pointed as this.
I really just wanted to say that I am quite happy that Jeffry voiced his opinion of the responses to the event as I too feel that it is important for Adobe to maintain consistency in their views about open source across product lines, regardless of the availability of open source projects within a particular camp. I also believe that it would be in the interest of Adobe to release an official statement of open source culture across product lines. Has Flex given up and conceded the market? I don’t think so, why would the CF team take this position?
I would like to invite Jeffry to discuss this topic further, be it here or within another venue, as I think the questions which have been posed are both important and interesting.












